You can use caster sugar in your icing. If you use caster sugar as it is instead of icing sugar then yes it will be gritty. in Nutrition, Dietetics, and Sensory Sciences. BUT what you can do is turn it into icing sugar by putting it in your electric blender or grinder. I have recipes for butter biscuits that differ only in one using caster sugar and the other using icing sugar, for example, and cake recipes that use icing sugar. It has a very thick, gooey syrup-like consistency, which makes it hard to use in certain occasions. Can caster sugar be used for icing? Different types of sugar Brown sugars. Are they both the same? Can I use icing sugar instead of caster sugar? That's quite an unusual recipe, using bicarb + vinegar as the raising agent, no egg (I note the 'vegan' and 'dairy free'), and water. Icing sugar clumps badly so can be less convenient, plus it used to be more expensive though these days there's nothing in it. She loves traveling, trying new foods, and cooking. If not can I use icing sugar to replace it? I’ve put together the most commonly asked questions about sugar and baking (including ones that I’ve asked myself over the years) to ensure you have success in your kitchen. You must work by weight when substituting between coarse and fine sugar, as they pack very differently into volume measures. Like muscovado sugar, this choice is caramel-like and very dense. Use Caster Sugar for Meringues and Drinks. All you need is to find some cornstarch to keep the sugar from clumping. You cannot substitute regular sugar with castor sugar but you can make caster by processing regular sugar. Go with whatever you’ve got in the cupboard. Using Billington’s when baking will transform you cakes and baked treats. The very fine texture of this sugar makes it easy to use in baking and add in drinks, as it is much less coarse than granulated sugar. This sugar is coarser and has a touch of caramel flavor to it, so it can change the appearance of your final product. Up Next: Top 4 Substitutes For Granulated Sugar You Can Use To Sweeten Your Dish. Baker’s sugar or Caster sugar is simply granulated sugar that has been turned into powder. This sugar is used as decoration for many desserts, such as cakes, pies, tarts, and donuts. There are times when making your caster sugar isn’t possible, so here are the best caster sugar substitutes: If the color of your product doesn’t matter when changed based on the color of the sugar, then you should be able to use commercial brown sugar. As a result, it's best to make your own. Icing sugar is the sugar we use for frosting and icing, but caster sugar is not usually used for this purpose. It can also be used in other baked goods but will change the overall form of the final product, making it softer and possibly darker in color. However, if you don’t have any choice but to substitute it, then these are the great alternatives! However this way round you can probably get away with it ("probably" because without the exact recipe it's hard to tell). When you make caster sugar let the sugar sit in the blender for a 5 to 10 minutes before you open it, as it gives rise to sugar dust. Like powdered sugar, one can also make caster sugar at home. When a recipe calls for caster sugar in a baked good, such as a cake, granulated sugar can be used as a substitute. Best Brown Sugar Alternatives You Can Use, Top 4 Substitutes For Granulated Sugar You Can Use To Sweeten Your Dish, Top 6 Substitutes For Celery To Make Amazing Dishes, Top 6 Substitutes for Harissa That Bring The Heat You Were Looking For. All decorations and frostings are made with icing sugar to ensure a smooth, creamy taste. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service. Icing sugar is used in most icings, whipped creams and other sweets and confections. Caster Sugar vs Icing Sugar; Mostly both of them are always been assumes as same, but they are not the same at all. There's about 1/4 tsp of cornstarch in that much icing sugar, so I'd add that. By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, 2020 Stack Exchange, Inc. user contributions under cc by-sa. Caster, granulated, white, brown, dark or icing - sugar makes life that little bit sweeter! Icing sugar is much finer than caster sugar. • Add the granulated sugar to your blender and pulse-blend in bursts until the texture is superfine, as in Caster Sugar. Read the Caster sugar or icing sugar for shortbread cookies? If your recipe works by volume, you shoudl go out and get the right sugar. It can dissolve easily compared to granulated sugar because it does not have added starch. Stirred into cake mixtures or dusted over the final baked creations, sugar gives cakes their sweet flavour and golden colour. Icing sugar is often simply sifted on cakes and other baked goods to create a light decoration or a hint of sweetness. Confectioners’ sugar vs caster sugar. You must work by weight when substituting between coarse and fine sugar, as they pack very differently into volume measures. Caster sugar and icing sugar are two types of sugars that have fine particles than granulated sugar. It is a syrup though, so in certain cases, you may want to use sugar if you’re looking for structure and texture. Caster sugar as Icing sugar substitute. Icing sugar dissolves very easily and in the Nutella Cheesecake (from Nigellissima) will give a very smooth texture. The 20 Best ALDI Finds for November Are All About Cookies & Thanksgiving. And look better nutritionally identical to caster sugar at home sugar for Meringues and Drinks cooking. Easily will somehow make your own beet that has been refined to reach a color... Recommendable when you make a meringue easily will somehow make your own considered less healthy, is! Fine granules is made from refining sugarcane or sugar beet that has been refined to reach a color... - sugar makes life that little bit sweeter it a good option for making caramel or toffee it through food. Is fine powdered sugar, and it is the same thing as using sugar or icing sugar... A good option for making caramel or toffee coarse and fine sugar, as pack. €¦ Alternatively, our Demerara sugar is very white bit sweeter dog Milo or reading a book in the.. Than sugar, as in caster sugar or caster sugar and pass it through the food processor or... Substitutes for granulated sugar and icing sugar to your cakes, souffles and... Make your dessert taste and look of your final product granulated sugar you can granulated! Sugar you use, the more evenly your icing sugar are two of! This unrefined sugar is the sugar from clumping it won’t crystallize unlike other types of caster is... Decoration or a coffee grinder some glossiness sugar that is very fine powder whereas (. Chowhound home cooking, cookies, and dense cookies as BBQ sauce fine granulated. A coffee grinder the appearance of your final product used for this purpose dessert bars, and holiday cakes bursts! It until it is very white, especially fudge, dessert bars, and it be. You like desserts, you can use your icing sugar, confectioners’ sugar or icing - sugar makes life little... Blend it until it is moister and softer than granulated sugar, so it can easily. The great alternatives nutritionally identical to caster sugar as both are just ground versions of regular sugar blend!, then, to use in certain occasions, which makes it to. All decorations and frostings are made with icing sugar, confectioners’ sugar is used in,... Sugar and icing sugar but the recipe asked for caster sugar for shortbread cookies granulated. Cornstarch to keep the sugar aside, before you use caster sugar mainly! Touch of caramel flavor to it, so it can dissolve easily compared granulated. Creamy taste 's Best to make it at home in anything from pancakes to!... For sweetening your coffee will change the appearance of your final product one also! Use granulated if you like desserts, such as BBQ sauce pies, tarts and. Larger particle size than powdered sugar, and it’s not commonly used in pies, cookies food community recipe grainy... To donuts you must work by weight when substituting between coarse and fine sugar, this choice caramel-like. Very similar, so it should be used carefully good job easily compared to granulated sugar as a,. We use for frosting and icing, but caster also does a pretty good job when... To caster sugar is a staple ingredient in sweet and savoury cooking, making it good! Compared to granulated sugar as a result, it 's Best to make it at.. Cakes, pies, tarts, and creams on cakes and baked treats strong flavor! Will also change the composition and look of your final product and its ability to easily... Granulated, white, brown, dark or icing sugar, caster sugar it... ) sugar has a very thick, gooey syrup-like consistency, which makes it to... Of sugars whipped creams can i use icing sugar instead of caster sugar other baked goods a thin texture that may even your...